Need help, newcomer with a hard headed springer

Discuss any aspect of training you have, ask questions, share tips and advice for any breed of gundog.
Cynic
Member
Posts: 301
Joined: Tue Jul 17, 2012 10:14 am

Re: Need help, newcomer with a hard headed springer

Post by Cynic »

springloaded wrote:
Cynic wrote:Prong collar is for heel work. I thought the issue was off lead?
Correct, well both really. In my estimation, the trainers view was that the obedience needs to be taught better on the lead first or else how would he comply off the lead. It was really my improper attempts a few moths ago that are the result, now I have to reteach the right way up close then work our way out to a 20' lead then no lead eventually. or at least thats the idea
Ill tell you what tho, It sure worked :lol:
So , It's a basic obedience issue. Like heel?
The tool for you is the prong collar because the simple slip lead had a combination of bad timing on your part and the fact that the slip lead was soft.
All this is a revelation or will be when the dog is off lead when a period of time is completed when the the dog has learned how to walk at heel ?
woolie
Member
Posts: 36
Joined: Sun Nov 17, 2013 4:56 pm
Location: nottingham

Re: Need help, newcomer with a hard headed springer

Post by woolie »

Your perseverance is commendable. I say you use whatever you can to help this dog understand and try and stick with a trainer you can laugh with . Also BEER IN THE FRIDGE for those bad days when you put him back in his kennel rather than CHOKE HIM........Good luck
springloaded
Member
Posts: 10
Joined: Wed Aug 13, 2014 1:02 pm
Dogs: Riggs
Location: New Jersey

Re: Need help, newcomer with a hard headed springer

Post by springloaded »

Cynic wrote:
springloaded wrote:
Cynic wrote:Prong collar is for heel work. I thought the issue was off lead?
Correct, well both really. In my estimation, the trainers view was that the obedience needs to be taught better on the lead first or else how would he comply off the lead. It was really my improper attempts a few moths ago that are the result, now I have to reteach the right way up close then work our way out to a 20' lead then no lead eventually. or at least thats the idea
Ill tell you what tho, It sure worked :lol:
So , It's a basic obedience issue. Like heel?
The tool for you is the prong collar because the simple slip lead had a combination of bad timing on your part and the fact that the slip lead was soft.
All this is a revelation or will be when the dog is off lead when a period of time is completed when the the dog has learned how to walk at heel ?
Correct. I wasnt getting the point across when I originally tried the basic obedience work and then compounded it by letting him run off on his own when he was younger. Now I have to go back to the begining and start the obedience the right way and work up to off the lead
Rascal
Co-Admin
Posts: 10211
Joined: Mon Nov 24, 2008 3:22 pm
Location: Lincolnshire

Re: Need help, newcomer with a hard headed springer

Post by Rascal »

springloaded wrote:

Correct. I wasnt getting the point across when I originally tried the basic obedience work and then compounded it by letting him run off on his own when he was younger. Now I have to go back to the begining and start the obedience the right way and work up to off the lead
When I train a pup it probably never has a lead on it for the best part of six months. I think where you went wrong was failing to capture this dogs attention on you and being the centre of all it's fun....The basics are taught in a fun way for the dog..As I said in an earlier post the dog needs to believe that all the rewards come from you..You don't control a dog from outward physical forces.....

Interesting article here......

http://suzanneclothier.com/the-articles ... ong-collar

And as she rightly points out....

If you're hanging on to your dog's body, it's because you've lost his mind....

I don't want to dish your trainer and the way you train your dog is your affair but you could achieve the same results with a slip lead...

Rascal
General Dogsbody
springloaded
Member
Posts: 10
Joined: Wed Aug 13, 2014 1:02 pm
Dogs: Riggs
Location: New Jersey

Re: Need help, newcomer with a hard headed springer

Post by springloaded »

Rascal wrote:
springloaded wrote:

Correct. I wasnt getting the point across when I originally tried the basic obedience work and then compounded it by letting him run off on his own when he was younger. Now I have to go back to the begining and start the obedience the right way and work up to off the lead
When I train a pup it probably never has a lead on it for the best part of six months. I think where you went wrong was failing to capture this dogs attention on you and being the centre of all it's fun....The basics are taught in a fun way for the dog..As I said in an earlier post the dog needs to believe that all the rewards come from you..You don't control a dog from outward physical forces.....

Interesting article here......

http://suzanneclothier.com/the-articles ... ong-collar

And as she rightly points out....

If you're hanging on to your dog's body, it's because you've lost his mind....

I don't want to dish your trainer and the way you train your dog is your affair but you could achieve the same results with a slip lead...

Rascal
I couldn't agree more. I did fail to capture the dogs attention from a young age. And this is where Im still a bit confused and perhaps you can help. Because there was a critical moment where I know I made a Mistake and I need to clarify it for the sake of the future. Every day since the day I picked him up from the breeder at 10 weeks, I took him out for walks in fields, woods, any kind of cover we might encounter later in life. I tried to make any commands, lessons ect. fun and easy to learn and it worked. everything was going great and he was learning well and at a quick pace. I remember almost exactly the day when things changed. it was late july this year and Id only had him for about 4 weeks. i was walking him through the woods and he just took off like a bullet. he came back after a few minutes and I didnt think much of It. well the next day the same thing occurred, and then, the day after that again. This is when I became worried and thought it was rare for a pup this young to be so bold. So I did what I thought was best and I contacted a professional. Thereafter I was I was instructed not to worry, to let the pup explore and find his legs. After he was 6 months I was to start the "training". So you can Imagine waht happened, he grew to have much more fun buggering around on his own then he could ever have with me. So why should he stay around me, when ther are so many squirrels to chase.

So, I think the trainer I saw this past weekend thought the prong collar might be the best way to undo what was done. Im sure If I had taken Riggs to him at 4 months, things likley would have been much different , but sometimes you have to do whatever it takes. I agree with you , you shouldnt have to force the dog into your way of thinking. the goal is to have him want to do it your way, or as you said, con him into thinking your way is the best, or only, way. But where I am at at this stage, perhaps its the only way?
Rascal
Co-Admin
Posts: 10211
Joined: Mon Nov 24, 2008 3:22 pm
Location: Lincolnshire

Re: Need help, newcomer with a hard headed springer

Post by Rascal »

I never or rarely take a pup on a walk where I'm going from A - B...With a pup right from the get go at eight weeks I start training the recall to voice and whistle, when I feed the pup and out on walks with either a treat or a tennis ball either given to the pup or tossed into light cover upon it's return, I mix it up to keep it's interest. I hide from a pup and give it loads of fuss when it finds me. I'm not actually walking anywhere...I walk backwards a lot and zig zag. I take it alone or occasionally with my older dogs as the pup takes it's cue from them, they have a built in radius and return to check in or on the recall whistle and the pup naturally follows.. The ground I use is varied but it's always game free initially although it might be scented once I'm more confident of the pups response to it's whistle commands...

I train the sit to whistle too by either food rewards and or a tennis ball tossed a short distance and I'm happy to let the pup run in on the ball...

If a pup were to bolt I wouldn't recall it if I wasn't confident of it's return but I sure as hell wouldn't be where that pup expected me to be when it returned, it would have to work hard to "find" me....But it would give me the heads up on the pups character and to recognise the signs of the pup hitting scent and bolting..I would do my level best to stop the pup bolting again, I wouldn't let the pup repeat that if I could help it..

It's a short window where a pup is totally dependant on me and I try to use it in a fun for the pup way, with all the fun and action taking place centred around me. I don't give pups meaningless retrieves in the house I do it in the big wide world. In a way that keeps the pups interest and stretches it slowly in short ten minutes or so sessions two or three times a day as a reward..But I stop whilst the pup is wanting more I want the pup very keen to retrieve and find retrieves and use that to keep the pups focus around me..

I don't wait for a pup to reach six months before I start "training" I do it in a fun way from the off...You've lost that window now to a large extent and I can't see you or your dog but you need to regain his focus on you somehow and I'm not sure using the prong collar as a way of teaching him to heel is the way to do it. As I said I'm not dishing your trainer and you appear happy with him and he can see you and your dog.

Rascal
General Dogsbody
Naj
Member
Posts: 7420
Joined: Tue Sep 20, 2011 11:47 am

Re: Need help, newcomer with a hard headed springer

Post by Naj »

I agree with Rascal. The 'leave 'em 'til 6 months then knock them into shape' school of thought is typically old school thinking & you were unfortunate in finding a trainer who still thinks in that way. As Rascal says, the first 6 months gives you a unique opportunity to develop the pup in the way that you want, rather than leaving it to choose its own way, as you have done. Don't now compound the problem by blaming it all in the dog, who is the innocent party in all this & just doing what dogs do when they lack guidance. It's still only a young dog so there is no reason why it shouldn't make a gundog with proper training. That doesn't mean to say you need to be hard on it to show it who is boss. Just train it. :think:

Naj
Cynic
Member
Posts: 301
Joined: Tue Jul 17, 2012 10:14 am

Re: Need help, newcomer with a hard headed springer

Post by Cynic »

7 pages back :lol:
Cynic wrote: Or train it?
Naj wrote: Just train it. :think:

Naj
Naj
Member
Posts: 7420
Joined: Tue Sep 20, 2011 11:47 am

Re: Need help, newcomer with a hard headed springer

Post by Naj »

Cynic wrote:7 pages back :lol:
Cynic wrote: Or train it?
Naj wrote: Just train it. :think:

Naj
Actually, I'm just reiterating what I advised on the second post on here, 9 pages back.
Cynic
Member
Posts: 301
Joined: Tue Jul 17, 2012 10:14 am

Re: Need help, newcomer with a hard headed springer

Post by Cynic »

Here was me thinking you were just repeating yourself :o
Merry Christmas
Post Reply