Gundog Training Forum

t jack wrote:then the 'line', is (imo) ...if thats what your looking for.
what i am saying, in my peculiar old fashioned way', 'if you want what it produced', go to what produced it!

But if Broc is producing is that not as good?[/quote]
it would depend on which bitch ?surely?

Polmaise wrote:

t jack wrote:then the 'line', is (imo) ...if thats what your looking for.
what i am saying, in my peculiar old fashioned way', 'if you want what it produced', go to what produced it!

But if Broc is producing is that not as good?

it would depend on which bitch ?surely?[/quote]

Could the same not be said for Brocs sire? (Genuine question) out of the choices if the sire of the other two ftch's is still available, then surely he's the safer bet? Going on your basis of using the dog which produced the dog?

I wasn't suggesting 'dog from the dog' mate,..purely on what had been asked fom OP.
From a breeding point of view however', it would make sense', that if you wanted what you see',or what you expect', then go to the same shop that makes the same 'bread'!
it is important at this point of the conversation to point out 'too close breeding however', in case 'clarity', of what has been said is 'mis interpreted'
The op', has indicated a choice of ?, three?? for opinion!..based upon the 'Sire'!
(dont want to be argumentative'?, just conversationalist?)
atvb
Robert

Polmaise wrote:I wasn't suggesting 'dog from the dog' mate,..purely on what had been asked fom OP.
From a breeding point of view however', it would make sense', that if you wanted what you see',or what you expect', then go to the same shop that makes the same 'bread'!
it is important at this point of the conversation to point out 'too close breeding however', in case 'clarity', of what has been said is 'mis interpreted'
The op', has indicated a choice of ?, three?? for opinion!..based upon the 'Sire'!
(dont want to be argumentative'?, just conversationalist?)
atvb
Robert

Sorry, i must have interpreted you wrongly, , on what basis did you suggest Brocs sire on then?

paul spaniel wrote:i personally wouldnt double up on the laganmill stuff

I have seen it mentioned that perhaps there may be health issues with doubling up on this, is that your only reason for this Paul?

Rookie wrote:

paul spaniel wrote:i personally wouldnt double up on the laganmill stuff

I have seen it mentioned that perhaps there may be health issues with doubling up on this, is that your only reason for this Paul?

PM me if you are seriously interested

Sgurr

Rookie wrote:

paul spaniel wrote:i personally wouldnt double up on the laganmill stuff

I have seen it mentioned that perhaps there may be health issues with doubling up on this, is that your only reason for this Paul?

yip, i have always been advised againest it..

paul spaniel wrote:

Rookie wrote:

paul spaniel wrote:i personally wouldnt double up on the laganmill stuff

I have seen it mentioned that perhaps there may be health issues with doubling up on this, is that your only reason for this Paul?

yip, i have always been advised againest it..

Thought this related to Maestro and Malvern only? Are you referring to the line generally Paul?

thanks boys (& girls!) blakeneys boy seems fav now. hope stenna have charitable rates!!!

arwesa wrote:Im intrested in this discussion, similar list here, not pepper though, but have edwardianna rob instead.

also what about cleeburf bramble?

where is edwardianna rob standing? dont here much of him down this way?