As Wullie & a few others have pointed out, it's only 4 months old etc. But I think they would also agree that it's not normal for a pup to be creating a noise at that age, & if it does, it is very likely to continue or get worse. I know that my heart would sink if a pup kicked off so very young. Whether I would get rid of it is another matter. Most 'squeakers' start at an older age, when they come into contact with game (never had a spaniel that made a noise as a pup). The only dog I've had that wittered as a pup - a GSP - carried this into old age, but it wasn't anywhere near as bad as what you describe. You sound like you have handled it as best you can & are consciouse about not rewarding it, but you are obviously anxious about it & this could possibly be picked up by the pup. If it is linked to you then it will be very difficult to eradicate. If it went to someone else then it may well disappear, but I wouldn't count on it. I know she is only young but is she getting enough free running, retrieving & outside stimulation to distract her attention away from you? Messing about with an insecure dog can try the patience of a saint, are you up for that? You sound to have lost confidence in this dog, which is, perhaps, understandable, but sooner or later you are going to have to make a decision on your commitment to her. What are you going to do in a years time if she is still the same? It's no help to your dog to have her owner stuck in a state of limbo.
Naj


